Sunday, July 14, 2013

"System errors" plague the NTSB and a San Francisco TV station



By now you have probably heard about the San Francisco TV station that broadcast what it thought were the names of the four pilots of Asiana Flight 214 that crashed landed last week.

The names were not those of the pilots and were typical racist stereotypes.

If you haven't seen it, here's a 30 second clip that shows all you need to know.

The station, of course, apologized and said that it had confirmed the names with the National Transportation Safety Board, which promptly blamed a "summer intern" for the debacle. This is according to an NBC News/Reuters story, one of the very few that didn't repeat the names.

That story also points out that the real names of the two pilots at the controls had been released earlier in the week.

Is another case of system errors and not human errors? Let's see.

The NTSB said, "Appropriate actions will be taken to ensure that such a serious error is not repeated." The intern was supposed to have referred such questions to official NTSB media people.

The station's vice president and general manager said, "Nothing is more important to us than having the highest level of accuracy and integrity, and we are reviewing our procedures to ensure this type of error does not happen again."

The apparently clueless anchorwoman who read the names has said, "A serious mistake was made."

Here is what spokespeople for the Asian American Journalists Association had to offer, "We are embarrassed for the anchor, who was as much a victim as KTVU's viewers and KTVU's hard-working staff."

Wait a sec. The anchor and KTVU's hard-working staff were victims?

"We never read the names out loud, phonetically sounding them out," said a different KTVU anchor.

Another AAJA member wrote, "Common sense indicates that simply sounding out the names would have raised red flags,"

Sound out the names? They were so obviously fake that a high school kid would have noticed simply by silently reading them.

How could everyone at the TV station, the producers, editors, writers and the anchor who read the story on the air with a straight face, not have noticed that the names were not only not very plausible, but also exceedingly offensive?

Also unclear is how the station acquired the supposed names in the first place.

System errors? I don't think so.

Additional source: Los Angeles Times

Search "System Errors" on my blog to see 12 other posts on this topic.

Wednesday, July 10, 2013

Transgastric appendectomy. Would you have one?



A study in the British Journal of Surgery says that removing an inflamed appendix via the stomach is feasible and "promising." This is what is known as NOTES or natural orifice transluminal endoscopic surgery.

The paper (full text plus videos under "Supporting Information" tab) describes the first 15 cases done at the University of Heidelberg in Germany.

There is so much wrong with this paper and the concept in general that it is hard to know where to start.

During the year from April 2010 to April 2011, 111 patients were offered the chance to have this procedure done and only 15 agreed to do so. It appears that patients have a lot more common sense than some physicians think. The patients were carefully selected. Those with BMIs > 30 and with perforated appendicitis were excluded

The procedure was done by inserting an endoscope through the mouth and then through the stomach wall,  but if you read only the abstract, you would miss the fact that a separate trocar was inserted via the umbilicus to facilitate the operation. Therefore, it is not a pure NOTES procedure. The NOTES crowd would call this a "hybrid" procedure.

Several complications occurred. The first case had to be converted to an open appendectomy because of "severe inflammation." This was not explained in the paper but was revealed in the typically uncritical MedPage Today article about it.

Two patients developed postoperative pelvic abscesses requiring what they called "laparoscopic revision" which is their euphemism for second operations. A second operation is very uncommon in patients without perforated appendicitis.

In one patient, a technical problem necessitated ligation of the stump of the appendix through the umbilical port. Another patient had bleeding which had to be controlled by clips. For an obese patient (curious, as only patients with BMIs < 30 were said to have been included), the appendix had to be cut into two pieces because it would not fit through the opening in the gastric wall.

The median duration of the NOTES cases was 105 minutes with a range of 59 to 150 minutes. The average time for a standard three-port laparoscopic appendectomy is about 25 to 35 minutes which means that the NOTES takes three times as long.

The median hospital stay was 3 days with a range on 1 to 8 days. The usual length of stay for a standard laparoscopic appendectomy in the United States is < 24 hours.

The heavily edited videos are worth a look, especially the fourth one, which shows that it takes at least 10 snips of the tiny endoscopic scissors before the appendix is completely divided.

Because of the two patients in the series who developed abscesses, the authors advise caution for those with purulent appendicitis and suggest doing a standard laparoscopic appendectomy instead. The problem is that the surgeon would not know that a patient has purulent appendicitis until she has looked and made what would then have been an unnecessary hole in the stomach.

Most standard laparoscopic appendectomy scars are invisible anyway. If just one patient suffered a leak of the stomach wall closure which would cause sepsis and other major complications, that would strongly negate the minimal cosmetic gain from the trans-gastric operation.

The study ended two years ago but was just published. I always wonder about that. What took so long? Was it rejected by other journals? You would think the authors would want this sort of breakthrough brought to light as soon as possible. Have they done more cases since then? What were the outcomes?

After reading the paper and seeing the videos, is there a surgeon in the world who would want a trans-gastric appendectomy performed on herself or a loved one? An unscientific Twitter poll indicated they would decline. One surgeon said, "Not sure if I'd answer 'No' or 'Hell No,' and I do NOTES research."

Here's the bottom line. Unless you have promised your patient trouble, only the most ardent proponent of NOTES could call these results "promising".


Live Chat Today (July 10) at noon EDT

Live chat on my blog today at noon EDT (GMT-4).

Topic: Why did so many people believe that doctors would be rating patients online? That story can be viewed here.

Any other topic you want to bring up is fine too.

Note: The Live Chat app is not yet available for mobile users and cannot be viewed by them.

Monday, July 8, 2013

Breaking news-Turning the tables: Doctors to rate patients online



This just in.


BREAKING NEWS--Turning the tables: Doctors to rate patients online. LINK

Friday, July 5, 2013

Follow up. How many authors does it take…?

I recently blogged about the fact that for several different specialties, the number of authors of research papers has risen exponentially over the years. The post appeared on General Surgery News.

As is my nature, I was critical of this increase and blamed it on the "publish or perish" culture that pervades medicine and other sciences and the large number of new journals, which all are looking for content so they can make money.

A Twitter follower named @terpkristin ask me what my own experience has been. This is a fair question and I applaud her for taking me to task on it.

With some trepidation, I pulled up my CV and started counting.

Over the years I have authored or co-authored 97 publications, including peer-reviewed articles and case reports, review articles, book chapters, editorials and letters to journal editors.

My first article was published in 1975 and the last in 2010. That's a span of 35 years which is similar to the times covered in many of the articles on author proliferation.

After reviewing all 97 publications, the average number of authors was 3.0 with 23 having only me as the sole author.

Excluding everything but the 52 peer-reviewed papers, the mean number of authors was 3.5.

Looking at the peer-reviewed papers another way, the 22 papers written from 1975 to 1993 had an average of 3.2 authors, while those written during 1994 to 2010 averaged 3.6 authors.

This compares favorably to the numbers of authors listed in the articles I found on the subject and wrote in my previous post.

For papers written in this century in the fields of plastic surgery, orthopedics and thoracic surgery, the average number of authors ranged from 4.0 to 7.5.

Luckily, my inquisitor didn't ask me how many of the articles were any good. That's a different question.

Monday, July 1, 2013

LIVE CHAT TODAY (July 1)

Live chat on my blog today (July 1) at 11 a.m. Eastern Daylight time in the US or GMT-4.

Chat app is located in the right lower portion of your screen.

The topic is "Should students and residents memorize information or should they google it?" If it's the latter, how should they be tested?

If you want to review some background information before the chat, I suggest you read the following:

Dumber Doctors?

Will Today's Medical Students Make Inferior Doctors Because They Google Medical Information Instead of Memorizing It?

Not Dumber, but Different? Counterpoint from a Millenial

Other topics may be discussed if time permits.

Friday, June 28, 2013

Blakemore tubes. Should an inexperienced surgeon use them?



In response to a comment mentioning Blakemore tubes on my post about what surgery was like in the 1970s, I said they were instruments of the devil.

This sparked the interest of surgeon who works in a rural hospital with minimal endoscopy services. He emailed me and asked if I thought he should have Blakemore tubes available for use because he might have to transfer a patient with bleeding esophageal varices over a long distance for definitive treatment.

He trained in the early 21st century and admitted that he did not remember ever having seen a Blakemore tube. He wondered why I didn't like it.

I have witnessed all of its major complications such as tube dislodgement, necrosis of the nose and lips, aspiration, esophageal perforation, airway occlusion and death.

Without any hands-on experience, he probably should not try to use the device. In addition, the average nurse would likely also not be familiar with caring for a patient with the tube.

On the other hand, maybe as a last resort he could try it.

I had planned to write a post about the Blakemore tube, its insertion, maintenance and complications. But while researching it, I found that others had done so, and better than I.

Read this excellent article on Medscape. Registration is required, but it is free. It covers everything you need to know about Blakemore tubes.

And here is a link to a nice video from the Yale GI service that demonstrates the steps required to safely insert and manage them.

What do you think? After reading the Medscape piece and watching the video, should this rural surgeon, who has never personally seen a Blakemore tube, use it ?