Monday, January 10, 2011

Twitter: The Good & the Bad

I’ve been on Twitter for about 6 months and have a modest following. I follow a few interesting people and organizations and generally am enjoying the experience. However, there are a some things I don’t understand.

Twitter offers suggestions regarding whom to follow based, I assume, on the current list of people I follow. Today it suggested I follow @[name deleted], who notably has 297 followers despite the fact that he has not posted a single tweet. [See photo.] I am not sure what to make of this since I have posted hundreds of tweets and have only 135 followers. Does this mean that if I stop tweeting, I can increase my list of followers by more than double? And what does it say about the 297? Do they know something that no one else does, like any day now @[name deleted] is going to tweet something quite profound? A partial explanation is that at least two of his followers are friends of his and when queried, they responded that they thought he would tweet.

I suppose it also is an indirect indictment of the people I follow. In other words, the people I follow are so interesting that Twitter feels a person who has never tweeted will fit right in.

Other people suggested by Twitter don’t appeal to me because almost all of their tweets are responses to other tweets which I have neither access to or interest in. It seems to me Twitter would be more effective if people would do more direct messaging or somehow be able to direct tweets to individuals. This would significantly reduce what I call “twutter” or Twitter-clutter.

I like the idea of communicating in 140 characters or fewer. It fosters a discipline that is lacking in the blogosphere where [unreadable] blogs of thousands of words abound.

Does Fluid Resuscitation Harm Trauma Patients?

A study published on line ahead of print in Annals of Surgery has attracted attention as it purportedly shows that trauma victims who received intravenous [IV] fluids in the pre-hospital setting fared worse than those who did not. Media outlets such as USA Today, the LA Times and Bloomberg Business Week all reported the findings uncritically. In fact, one version of the HealthDay story quoted the conclusion of the paper’s abstract which definitively states that IV fluids should not be used. That is why reading only abstracts can be misleading.

While I tend to agree with the premise that IV fluid administration might raise the blood pressure and actually promote further bleeding, the paper’s conclusion that the routine use of IV fluid resuscitation for all trauma patients should be discouraged is not supported by its data.

Here are some of the problems with the paper:

1. The paper is based on data from the National Trauma Data Bank, a voluntary database contributed to by over 600 trauma centers. The data may not be entirely reliable. For example, the paper reviewed data from the years 2001-2005. Of 1,466,887 possible patients, only 776,734 (53%) had pre-hospital data to review.
2. The only mention of an IV in the raw data is whether or not an intravenous catheter was inserted. The database contained no information on the amount of IV fluid given at the scene of the trauma, during transport to the hospital or even in the emergency department. This renders the title of the paper “Prehospital Intravenous Fluid Administration is Associated With Higher Mortality in Trauma Patients: A National Trauma Data Bank Analysis” somewhat suspect.
3. During the years studied, scene and transport times were not collected. It is possible that the problem leading to the poorer outcomes in the patients who had IV lines placed is increased time wasted at the scene and not necessarily the IV fluid itself.
4. According to the database, more than half of the patients who had an IV started also had Military Anti-Shock Trousers [MAST] placed. This is hard to believe since the use of MAST was discredited years ago. And of the patients who did not have an IV inserted, only 0.19% had MAST applied. Perhaps the MAST is doing the damage and not the IV.

I asked the lead author of the study, Dr. Elliott R. Haut, to comment on my criticisms and he said, “I agree that our study is not perfect for some of the reasons you cite and others as well. Retrospective data studies like this are fraught with potential problems and cannot truly define causality. However, I do continue to feel strongly that our study, along with all of the other data on the subject, suggest [sic]that IV fluids are not all benefit without harm. More research needs to occur to figure out the best practices.” This is a much softer statement that that of the abstract of the paper which concluded “The harm associated with prehospital IV fluid administration is significant for victims of trauma. The routine use of prehospital IV fluid administration for all trauma patients should be discouraged."

Tuesday, January 4, 2011

Patients Are Not Airplanes

As promised in my post “Surgeons Are Not Pilots,” today I will address the issue of whether patients can be compared to airplanes. Honestly, I cannot think of even one thing that patients have in common with airplanes.

As alluded to yesterday, probably the most glaring difference is that, unlike an airplane, each patient is unique. If a pilot sits at the controls of any Airbus A320 aircraft, he can be reasonably sure that pulling back the stick a certain amount will result in a very consistent response from the plane. Therefore, practicing on a simulator will enable the pilot to prepare for any emergency with the knowledge that what he did on the simulator will in fact be reproducible in a real emergency.

Contrast that with a patient. Often patients with similar illnesses will behave very differently because human beings are not engineered like airplanes. For example, let’s say I am performing a difficult laparoscopic cholecystectomy (removal of the gallbladder) and I am having trouble locating the cystic artery (artery to the gallbladder). I know that the anatomy of the cystic artery is highly variable. This link illustrates 11 of the most common anatomic variations in the location of that vessel. This means that there is not a simple maneuver that will help me find the artery in every case.

A pilot can be confident that a 5% increase in power will result in a very predictable response in airspeed. Contrast that with a patient’s response to a medication. I have had patients fall asleep with an intravenous injection of only 2 mg of morphine and I’ve had other patients who loudly complain of persistent pain after receiving 10 mg of the same drug.

A word about simulators. Because all stimuli are external to a fixed object, the pilot, aircraft simulators are easy to design and are very realistic. They recreate the motion, sounds and visuals of flying very well. When I was in the Navy stationed on an aircraft carrier, I heard pilots talk about their experiences in simulators. They said the intensity of the experience was very similar to that of flying a real plane. While surgical simulators have become more sophisticated, they still lack the realism of aircraft simulators because the action is all occurring on a video screen and the surgeon is sitting in a lab somewhere. There is no way that a surgical simulator can give you the adrenaline rush and anal sphincter-puckering feeling of seeing a sudden squirt of blood that covers your laparoscope and totally obscures your vision during a tough case. And there are no realistic surgical simulators for open (non-laparoscopic) cases. Operating on a pig just doesn’t cut it. (Pun intended.)

So please, stop trying to compare patients to airplanes.

A postscript on yesterday’s “Surgeons Are Not Pilots” blog.

Captain Chesley Sullenberger, the appropriately acclaimed hero of the successful Hudson River landing of US Airways Flight 1549, is hardly a typical pilot. According to one biography, he had over 27,000 hours of flying experience with more than 19,000 of those hours in Airbus A320s or like aircraft. He also had written about air safety and worked as an NTSB investigator. The hours alone qualified him as an “expert” pilot.

Compare Sully’s background with that of the pilots of Colgan Air Flight 3407, which crashed in Buffalo two years ago, killing 50 people. The following is from the Wikipedia entry about this incident, “The crew of four was led by Captain Marvin Renslow … who was hired by Colgan in 2005 and had flown 3,379 hours. 261 of these hours were on the Dash-8 Q400 (including 109 as a captain). First Officer Rebecca Lynne Shaw … was hired by Colgan in January 2008, and had flown 2,200 hours, 772 of them on the Q400.” The cause of the fatal accident was several pilot errors and failures to follow protocols.

All the checklists in the world didn’t prevent that crash. As long as humans are going to perform surgery on other humans, bad outcomes will occur. Yes, we should endeavor to minimize errors as much as possible, but “zero defects” and Six Sigma are not possible in medicine (or even in manufacturing).

Monday, January 3, 2011

Surgeons Are Not Pilots

I am sick of hearing that surgeons can be compared to pilots. Yes, there are some similarities and some things can be learned from the aviation industry. For example, I am a big fan of checklists, having used them in both the operating room and intensive care settings. Both a GS and an FP will have occasion to multitask and both need to have what is termed “situational awareness” or an understanding of where he is and what is going on around him. But let’s look at some of the differences between specifically, general surgeons (GS) and fighter pilots (FP).

The training of surgeons and pilots is remarkably different. This table illustrates some of the differences.

Total hours of training for a GS after medical school can be broken down as follows. Five years of residency training at 80 hours/week equals 20,800 hours. Allowing for 6 hours of sleep/night (Ha!) over five years would reduce the actual training time to 15,600 hours of which some 2000 hours would be spent in the operating room (about 1000 cases performed by the average graduating chief resident at about 2 hours/case).

Total hours of training for an FP entering the US Air Force are as follows. (Note: data are from a paper by a USAF colonel who is also a surgeon.) Once accepted to flight school, the neophyte first takes 50 hours of civilian flight training and becomes certified as a private pilot. Then he goes to Phase I or preflight training which apparently involves ground training, survival, navigation etc and no actual flying. Phase II is six months of flight training with 90 hours of flight time in a jet trainer. Phase III is another 6 months of training with 120 hours of flying in the aircraft to which they have been assigned. The entire package takes about two years at let’s say 10 hours per day or 5200 hours (50 hours/week x 52 weeks x 2years) of which some 260 hours is actually spent in the air.

To illustrate this point more clearly, someone once said, “I know a lot of doctors who became recreational pilots, but I don’t know one pilot who became a recreational doctor.”

If what Malcolm Gladwell says is true that one needs to spend 10,000 hours at a task before one can be considered an “expert”, I leave it to you to decide whether surgeons and pilots are experts.

Some thoughts on this from surgeons in the UK:

“If a pilot were to undertake all the roles required by a consultant surgeon, he/she would interview separately every potential passenger for every flight that he/she was responsible for. He would then have to determine for each passenger the optimum way of reaching their destination; it may well be that rail, road or sea travel would be better for that particular individual than air travel. [T]he captain would need to obtain informed consent from every passenger to ensure that they understood what flying involved, including the risk of infection in aircraft, the risks related to the type of ventilation being used for that particular flight, the risks of deep vein thrombosis and pulmonary embolism, the risks of a major air disaster, the risks of air turbulence, etc.” It goes on.

“When was the last time you talked to your pilot? Please let the analogy end.”

Coming soon: “Patients Are Not Airplanes”

Thursday, December 30, 2010

Sleep-Deprived Surgeons: Idealism and Reality


An editorial in the this week’s New England Journal of Medicine proposes that sleep-deprived surgeons should tell patients that information and obtain written consent from patients acknowledging that they have been so informed. This article garnered a “hat trick” of coverage as it was featured by Science Daily, Medpage Today and Eurekalert. First, let’s look at the coverage. Understanding that these three sites simply rehash press releases, they do tend to resemble news reports. Only Medpage Today, while publishing a photo [at right] of a seemingly fatigued surgeon, chose to mention a rebuttal to the editorial by the American College of Surgeons [ACS]. One the other hand, CNN Health published a somewhat balanced report that included excerpts from the ACS response but follow-up answers were forthcoming only from one of the editorial’s co-authors and not the ACS spokespersons.

I would point out that this sentence from the proposal, “In surgery, there is an 83% increase in the risk of complications (e.g., massive hemorrhage, organ injury, or wound failure) in patients who undergo elective daytime surgical procedures performed by attending surgeons who had less than a 6-hour opportunity for sleep between procedures during a previous on-call night” is grossly misleading. The JAMA paper cited says no such thing. Yes, there is an increased risk of complications but the paper does not specify exactly which complications occurred. They may in fact have been minor complications. Of course, “massive hemorrhage, organ injury, or wound failure” sounds much more dramatic.

Although the rebutting ACS leaders made a decent point that issues such as marital problems, a sick child or financial difficulties might also degrade performance and are not subject to disclosure, the argument that surgeons should be trained to recognize fatigue was extremely weak and was deftly parried by one of the co-authors of the proposal. You can read those comments in the CNN Health article.

Now, what do I think of the proposal? In a perfect world, the idea of a surgeon telling patients that he is sleep-deprived would be wonderful. Alas, we don’t live in a perfect world. The reality is the proposal is highly impractical. The example cited in the proposal was that a surgeon who was up all night had an elective colostomy scheduled for 9 a.m. The proposal’s authors would mandate that he inform the colostomy patient that he is sleep-deprived and offer the patient the option to postpone the procedure or have another surgeon perform it. What is involved in postponing the case? The patient may have taken laxatives to prepare the bowel for surgery. She may have had lab work done, taken time off from work, arranged for child care, have important business three weeks later etc. The hospital’s operating room likely would go unused for the two hours originally booked for the colostomy.

Having another surgeon operate on the patient would mean loss of a fee for the tired surgeon. [I know that shouldn't matter but it's not a perfect world.] And just which surgeon is going to be sitting around doing nothing that morning and hoping a colleague was sleep-deprived? Assuming another surgeon was readily available, how does the conversation between the patient and the new surgeon go? “Hi, I’m your new surgeon. I’m not sleep deprived. By the way, what’s wrong with you? Oh, you need a colostomy.” Does the patient have a chance to Google the new surgeon? Is the new surgeon on the patient’s insurance panel? What if the patient doesn’t bond with the new surgeon in the 10 minutes she has had to get to know him? Can she ask for a third surgeon to be introduced? Will all of this take so long that the original surgeon might have had a chance to take a nap and now be refreshed? How long of a nap is long enough?

Maybe the solution is for every hospital to establish a surgical hospitalist service to do all the acute care surgery. This would allow some surgeons to focus on elective surgery exclusively. This too would cost significant money in terms of supporting the hospitalist service and loss of income and new patients for surgeons who no longer take call. Also, where are all these surgical hospitalists going to come from? [Full disclosure: Skeptical Scalpel is a surgical hospitalist.]

Bottom line. I see no way that the proposal that a sleep-deprived surgeon must obtain informed consent from patients is practical in today’s medical setting.

Saturday, December 25, 2010

Christmas Morning Then and Now

It’s a quiet Christmas morning sitting by the fire with my wife. The children aren’t awake yet. They are all grown up now but I’m glad they are home with us today. My fondest memory of Christmas morning is from their pre-teenage years. We had a rule that none of the kids could go downstairs to see what Santa brought until every one of the six of them were awake.

Inevitably, one of them would sleep late. So my oldest son, who was then about 8, would be the first to crawl into bed with us to wait. As he lay between my wife and me, his heart was pounding with excitement. Each beat almost shook the bed. One by one the others appeared until our bed was filled with a quivering mass of high anticipation.

Finally the last one arose, and they all raced down the stairs. In those days, I videotaped the fun of Christmas. At some point amid the mountains of strewn wrapping paper and boxes, one of them would always look up and say, “This is the best Christmas ever.”

I’m thankful that they are all happy adults. In a different way it’s still “the best Christmas ever.”

Wednesday, December 22, 2010

NY Times Wedding Profile Ignites the Internet: Grammatical and Medical Implications

So there’s this big dustup about a couple whose wedding was profiled in the NY Times on Sunday. It seems in the process of discovering they were soul mates, they broke up two marriages, both with children, the two couples had been friends and blah, blah, blah. The Times had to shut down the comments section of the story because of the furor.

Then Slate posted some sort of blog about it and among the comments is a biblical reference by a person with the apparent pseudonym “Guest.” [Or maybe it was Christopher Guest but I doubt it because he likely would have known better.] Anyway, include in Guest’s numerous ramblings was this “Let he who is without sin throw the first stone.”

Forget about the wedding. I have to unload about the comment. The exhortation “Let he who is without sin throw the first stone” is from the Book of John something:something. Various versions of the passage exist [Google it yourself and see]. But the correct way to say this is “Let him who is without sin throw the first stone.” If you don’t believe me, try this. Delete the clause “who is without sin” and say what remains “Let he throw the first stone.” Can you appreciate that it just don’t sound right?

By the way, two comments by others suggested the bride and groom are narcissists. Please don’t forget that narcissism is no longer a disease. It’s been relegated to the status of just being a very annoying personality trait.